We offer 12 flavors each week. The Exceptional Eight are always available, plus two featured flavors of the month and two weekly flavors. Exceptional Eight- Vanilla Bean, Death by Chocolate, Red Velvet, Unicorn, Bart Simpson, Cookies and Cream, Strawberry Shortcake, Key Lime Cheesecake

 For the rotating features, we pull from our signature flavors, seasonal specialties, or any creation that we're feeling especially sweet about that week.


Check out our ordering page or call us at 757-675-3966 to place an order for cupcakes or cookies off our menu!

Orders can be placed and prepaid online prior to 11pm the night before. If you would like more than 6 cupcakes of one flavor it is considered a special order due to baking schedules and ingredients. We do require at least 48 hours notice to fill an order of 6 or more of one flavor. Special orders for flavors not on the current weekly menu are available by emailing us at with at least 72 hours notice. Pick up at the Sugar Shack 2724 Virginia Beach Blvd. Virginia Beach, VA 23452.

Meet The Cupcakes

Exceptional Eight

Death By Chocolate.JPGDeath by Chocolate 

Our rich Callebaut chocolate cupcake is covered with our mousse like Callebaut chocolate frosting, then drizzled with our amazing chocolate ganache. One bite of this one and you will think you have died and gone to heaven.

Vanilla Bean.JPG  Vanilla Bean

 This is our traditional vanilla cupcake made with the best Madagascar vanilla and then topped with or amazing fluffy vanilla bean frosting. We top it with sprinkles or other fun things so it is ready to celebrate any occasion or holiday.  

Bart Simpson.JPG  Bart Simpson

This is our chocolate cupcake frosted with a creamy peanut butter buttercream rolled in crushed butterfingers. Topped with an extra swirl of peanut butter buttercream and a peanut butter ganache drizzle. 

Unicorn.JPG Unicorn

This is a funfetti cupcake frosted with cotton candy buttercream, rolled in rainbow sugar crystals. Topped with a swirl of vanilla colored buttercream, a unicorn horn and sparkle. 


Cookies and Cream.JPGCookies and Cream

A fluffy vanilla cupcake with oreo pieces baked right in. Frosted with an oreo buttercream, sprinkled with crushed oreos and an oreo cookie. 

Keylime Cheesecake.JPGKeylime Cheesecake

   A fresh fluffy keylime cupcake with a graham cracker crust and a swirl of keylime cheesecake baked right in. Frosted with a keylime cream cheese buttercream, rolled in crushed graham crackers. Topped with an extra swirl of buttercream and a keylime glaze drizzle. 

Strawberry Shortcake.JPGStrawberry Shortcake 

A fluffy vanilla cupcake cored and filled with strawberry compote. Frosted with a strawberry buttercream and topped with white chocolate curls. 

Red Velvet.JPGRed Velvet

Our take on the classic red velvet cupcake. It was approved by Florian himself when we were on Cupcake Wars. It is the perfect red brown color. We add buttermilk and a hint of cocoa powder and finish with our delightful light fluffy cream cheese frosting. This one is a crowd pleaser.

Highlighted Monthly
Flavors for September

Black and White Tux.JPGBlack and White Tux

 A rich chocolate cupcake cored and filled with a marshmallow cream. Frosted with vanilla buttercream, dipped in chocolate ganache and drizzled with white chocolate.

Snickerdoodle Cheesecake.JPGSnickerdoodle Cheesecake 

A fluffy vanilla cupcake with a swirl of cinnamon cheesecake baked right in. Frosted with a cream cheese buttercream rolled in cinnamon sugar. Topped with an extra swirl of buttercream and a cinnamon glaze drizzle. 

Highlighted Flavors
for the week

9-14-20 to 9-20-20

Chocolate Birthday Cake.JPG Classic Birthday  

   A classic vanilla cupcake frosted with a chocolate buttercream topped with confetti sprinkles.


A classic almond wedding cake frosted with an almond vanilla bean buttercream topped with white chocolate curls.

The Diva Sampler is our most popular, fan-favorite assortment, with your choice of 6 cupcakes from the current menu. Offered at a special, family-friendly price of only $17.50 - that's like getting one for free! For an even better deal, grab our Diva Dozen for only $33.00.
It's like getting TWO CUPCAKES FOR FREE!

Baby Cake Diva Samplers feature mini versions of our standard cupcake. They come 12 to a box, with a mix of 6 flavors from our current menu. Our bakers choose the flavors. At only $16, they offer a taste of all the Twisted goodness.
Twisted Sisters Cupcakes bakes with nuts, wheat and dairy.
Although we make it very hard to resist temptation, we urge those with allergies not to consume our cupcakes.



Meet The Cookies



Exceptional Eight Cookies

Chocolate Chip.JPGChocolate Chip Cookie

Soft baked chewy chocolate chip cookie made with gourmet ingredients including ghiradelli milk and dark chocolate chips and madagascar bourbon vanilla.

Oatmeal Raisin.JPGOatmeal Raisin Cookie

 Soft baked chewy oatmeal cookie filled with rolled oats, organic raisins, and madagascar bourbon vanilla. 

Peanut Butter.JPGPeanut Butter Cookie

Chewy Peanut Butter cookie rolled in sugar crystals and baked to perfection, just like grandma used to make.

Classic Sugar.JPGClassic Sugar 

For the purist. This chewy soft baked cookie is a classic. The simple flavors of butter, vanilla bean and sugar crystals is anything but plain.

Double Chocolate

A rich chewy chocolate cookie with chunks of chocolate all throughout. 


A soft chewy half brownie half chocolate chip cookie.


A soft chewy classic sugar cookie full of sprinkles rolled in more sprinkles.


This soft baked sugar cookie is rolled in cinnamon and sugar for the perfect bite of sweet and spice.


No need to search any further for the best cookies in Hampton Roads. Our cookies are made with the best ingredients including sweet cream butter, ghiradelli chocolate, saigon cinnamon and madagascar vanilla. We took your favorite cookies from gandmas house and transformed them into jumbo gourmet cookies.

Our jumbo gourmet cookies are $2.25 each, but why settle for just one! We offer 6 cookies for $10.00 (that is almost two FREE cookies!) or a bakers dozen (13 cookies) for $20.00 (that is four FREE cookies!!)

Twisted Sisters Cupcakes bakes with nuts, wheat and dairy.
Although we make it very hard to resist temptation, we urge those with allergies not to consume our desserts.